It really pisses me off when sexual minorities try to make their identities palatable to the mainstream by saying "it’s not really about sex."
I’ve heard it from all sides. Queer folks try to make it seem like their status as outsiders to the mainstream is all about politics, rather than about the basic fact that they want to fuck people of the same sex and that gets most of the world upset. Queerness didn’t start with rainbow flags and Advocate magazine and legislative activism. It started in our crotches.
I’ve heard BDSMers wax poetic about how play is "more than" sex, something on a higher plane, something not tainted by the rutting that mere vanilla people commit for their down-market version of pleasure. What the fuck? People, you do this because it makes you horny.
Sure, BDSM play and relationships can be platonic, and they can be spiritual, and they can be about community. BDSM can be beautiful in all kinds of ways that aren’t about sex per se. But that’s not the same thing as distancing what we do from sex as though sex were dirty and we were pure. Kinky folk often find pleasure easier or more intriguing to access through whips and restraints than through the missionary position, but that does not make BDSM better than sex in some cosmic way, or purer than sex, or otherwise unrelated to sex. Kink is sex expanded, not sex dismissed.
And last but not least, I’ve heard polyamorous people over and over explain that polyamory is all about love and relationships, and - wait for it - not about sex. Crikey! Okay, dating three people is not about sex in the same way that dating one person is not about sex. In other words… yes, it is about sex! Or at the very least there’s a lot of "about sex" involved!
Of course there’s more to it as well - lots more. But it’s not like polyamorous people decided to become that way because they just needed an extra pair of hands to help cook dinner one night, or had a hankering to talk politics with someone other than their spouse. Non-poly people get that stuff too, from other folks in their lives commonly called "friends."
Face it: people who are poly want to sleep with more than one person. We just want to do it ethically, and we open up the possibility of having additional relationships rather than simply heading for the local swingers’ club for some anonymous boinking. But lots of poly people do go to swingers’ clubs too, and lots of us have all kinds of sex-related fun outside "loving, committed relationships."
The Chicago Tribune online just published an article entitled "A poly life: monogamy with more partners" (http://metromix.chicagotribune.com/tv/mmx-0602210332feb22,0,13159.story?coll=mmx-television_heds if you’re curious to read it). The title alone made me wrinkle my nose, and it got worse from there. Check out this paragraph in particular:
"Monogamists often confuse polyamory with swinging, a practice that gained notoriety in the 1970s. Robyn Trask, managing editor of Loving More, a magazine based in Boulder, Colo., devoted to the poly lifestyle, defines polygamy as simply "monogamy with more people." Other defenders point to the fact that practicing "polys" don’t engage in one-night stands."
Excuse me? Who the hell came up with the "fact" that poly people don’t do one-nighters? I beg to differ. Of course some poly people don’t do one-nighters, but I resent any effort to sanitize polyamory by saying none of us do. I did not get into an alternative lifestyle to be told I can’t sleep with people unless we’re bloody married!
For me, poly is not just a multiplication of monogamies. It is a wholly different way of looking at the world of love, sex and relationships. It is the freedom, through honesty and communication and trust, to follow my desires wherever they take me, whether that be into the arms of a charming stranger for a couple of hours or into a lifelong partnership with someone other than my main squeeze. It is the real-life incarnation of that saying, "If you love someone, let them go. If they love you, they will come back to you. If they don’t, then they never loved you in the first place." I let my lovers go every moment of every day, and they come back to me, and this is how I know what we have is real. It doesn’t matter if they go to a long-distance lover, to a one-night stand, or to their wife or husband. It doesn’t matter if they go to sex or love or cuddling or porn or intimate friendship. It’s the coming back that counts, and the freedom to go in the first place.
For me, queer is about what makes me wet first and foremost. I love the film festivals and the bookstores and the social groups and the Pride parade, but I love them because to me they are a celebration of the legitimacy of those desires, not a replacement of them. I am queer because I think women and genderqueers and trans people are hot, as well as men. I am an activist because I recognize that my desires, multiplied several-hundred-thousandfold by others’ desires of similar sorts, place people like me into positions of being discriminated against and abused and sometimes even killed. But my queerness did not come from politics; it led me there.
For me, kink has always been a part of who I am. I don’t know what my sexuality would look like if there were no power or pain involved. It’s been there in every relationship I’ve ever had, in every fantasy, in every image that made me look twice in a movie or on the pages of a magazine. Until a few years ago, I didn’t understand the point of SM clubs and groups and leather clothing. BDSM started in my head and in my panties, and it moved into my bedroom, and I saw no reason to dress up and go out looking for it in a bar somewhere.
When my ex brought me to a fetish night at a local club a few years ago, I instantly felt like I fit in, and I’ve been around ever since. I’ve found good people there - allies, friends, teachers and partners. I’ve discovered the pleasures of finding the perfectly fitted corset and the perfectly balanced flogger. I’ve learned techniques I might never have dreamed of on my own, and discovered safe ways to make some of my fantasies come to life. I’ve worked with some of the most committed community-building activists I’ve ever had the privilege of encountering. And yes, I have widened my understanding of the pleasures of power and pain into areas outside sex - areas that are intriguing and fun and powerful without getting me horny.
But the reason I felt a kinship with the people at that first fetish night, and at hundreds of other fetish nights since then, is because I could see in all their diversity that they’d found their turn-ons outside the world of roses and soft caresses, and sought to satisfy those desires by banding together with others who share them. They weren’t just looking for a new way to make friends. They didn’t see overhand whipping as a simple alternative to tricep pulldowns at the gym. They weren’t looking for a spiritual experience one fine Saturday night. And they didn’t mistake the kink boutique for a tack shop and stick around because the riding crops were cheaper. They found the community because their sexual desires led them there.
If all the shops and clubs and websites shut down tomorrow, my sexuality would still be about power and pain. Now I have some non-sexual power and pain to add to my repertoire, but I will never forget that the starting point here was following the fantasies and practices that get me off. BDSM has expanded my range, but it has not sidestepped my clit along the way.
Queer is about sex. BDSM is about sex. Polyamory is about sex. They are, or at least can be, about other things too, all kinds of beautiful and valid things - like love, trust, communication, politics, challenge, self-awareness, support, community, spirituality, activism, advocacy, aesthetics, friendship, fun and learning. But the unifying factor here is that they started with sex.
To say otherwise is to say that sex is not a legitimate form of human experience. To say otherwise is to agree with the people who are trying to repress and oppress us, to say that sex is bad and dirty and sinful and illegitimate and threatening and dangerous and scary and ugly and sick. To say otherwise is to play right into the agendas of the people who want to stop us from getting off in the way we see fit and with whomever we see fit.
It is about sex, and I for one like that little "fact" just fine.