wearing pink does not mean you’re queer-friendly
Saturday, July 29th, 2006So I’ve somehow managed to find myself attending a couple of Outgames events in spite of myself. First of all, my friend C had purchased a ticket to one day of the Right To Be Different Conference, this past Thursday, and was unable to make it, so she generously offered it to me and I grabbed at the chance to attend without shelling out. It was a very interesting experience, and I’ll post about it when it’s not 2:10 a.m. and I don’t have a raging headache.
Second of all, the opening ceremony tickets went on two-for-one special yesterday, and my friend L wanted to go halvsies with someone, so I said yes. I went for Cirque du Soleil and kd lang, and they didn’t disappoint, but sadly they were about all I found satisfying; the rest was OK, but just like any other stadium show with lots of lighting and bad reverberating sound. I particularly enjoyed the wonderful moment at which kd, while singing her classic Miss Chatelaine, crooned the line "IIIIII can’t explaaaaaaiin why I’ve becoooooome Miss Chatelaine," only glanced down at her very butch self, clad in an untucked plaid shirt with chinos, and replaced the "Miss" with a "Mister" and a big rueful grin. There was scattered laughter and applause - I don’t think everyone quite caught on, but those who did appreciated it. Delightful.
But the true highlight of the evening was one of the speeches before the show even started. Now, I’m sure most of you are familiar with how opening ceremonies work at big events like this - they trot out the people who have organized and supported the event, and those people wear suits and ties and give speeches that all basically come down to the same thing: "We’ve worked really hard, congratulations to everyone involved, please have a great time at the event." They’re generally boring as hell, but you sit through them and applaud politely and wait for the fun stuff to happen (assuming it’s the kind of event where fun stuff happens at all). The Outgames opening was no exception - lots of politicians making their vote-for-me congratulate-the-gays speeches before the entertainment portion of the show. I spent a lot of time people-watching and writing in my journal, waiting for the good part to start.
Until the federal government representative got up behind the podium. I didn’t catch his name - all I know is that it was a balding guy in a grey suit with a pink shirt (how à propos). The reason I didn’t catch his name is because as soon as he was introduced as a member of the federal (i.e. Conservative) government, the entire fucking stadium started to boo. It was like someone had given a cue. And they kept booing so loudly that I didn’t hear a single word of his entire speech. It was so bad that partway through, the mayor of Montreal, Gérald Tremblay, got up and interrupted the speech, and said, "Please, please! Listen, listen! We are in the city of Montreal!" - at which the audience cheered wildly, also as though on cue - "And I ask that you listen with respect to the message from the representative of our federal government!" - at which everyone went right back to booing again, and continued to do so until Pink Shirt got off the stage.
It was painful. Oh god, it was awful. And yet there was a terrible sort of beauty about it.
As I watched it all unfold, I had four things running through my head at once. The first one: wow, people here really do feel incredibly strongly about the Conservatives. I’m not surprised at the lack of enthusiasm, but I didn’t realize it was at quite this level of quasi-unanimous and vehement hostility.
Second: that poor bastard up there on stage. How incredibly awful it must feel to get all dressed up to come speak at a huge event and realize that the thousands upon thousands of people filling the stadium all hate your guts. I mean, getting booed for three minutes straight while you’re trying to deliver a happy little congratulations speech - that’s gotta really suck!
Third: What were the conference organizers thinking when they brought this guy in to speak? Is it because the government provided funding and they had to invite a rep? Did they realize the reaction would be so bad? Did they expect the queers to shut up and be nice when a figurehead from the government that wants to remove our recently-won rights gets up there and starts spouting "we love the gays" rhetoric that’s clearly a load of complete hypocrisy? Wow. Major error in judgment there. (A friend of mine suggested the organizers might have known exactly what would happen, but I’m not sure I give them that much credit.)
Fourth: Well, there you have it. If there were any doubts in that particular Conservative’s mind about how the queer vote will go, they have now surely disappeared. The audience’s reaction might have been rude, but it was sharply accurate. Queers hold a grudge, and as a community, we’ve got more political power than ever before right now. What do we care if we embarrass the Outgames organizers and offend Pink Shirt the hypocrite fed? His party expressly intends to strip us of our political gains - what does he want, a bouquet of flowers and a blow job?
Of course lots of us aren’t big believers in the marriage thing, and of course there are all kinds of power and privilege problems (watch for a rant about how the Outgames conference exemplified that, coming soon) in the queer world that mean certain relatively light issues get addressed while much more pressing needs go ignored. So I’m not saying I agree wholesale with all the purposes for which queer political power is being used; far from it. But I am saying that the booing was a shameless, rude, obnoxious, and perfectly crystal-clear illustration of the way the vast majority of queers feel about a government that’s socially conservative, and I gotta say I stand behind it.
It felt like watching a train wreck, but it was a train that deserved its wrecking, and the conductor should have seen it coming miles away.